Safety / toxicology 2025

Trace element speciation in edible mushrooms: a review of analytics and risk assessment (As, Cr, Se, Hg, Sb)

A review of trace-element speciation in edible mushrooms (arsenic, chromium, selenium, mercury, antimony): analytical methods, literature data, risk assessment. Key findings: chromium barely bioaccumulates, antimony is mostly Sb(V), mercury builds up on contaminated sites, ~10% of samples exceed inorganic-arsenic limits.

Krakowska A. et al. Decoding trace element speciation in mushrooms: Analytical techniques, comprehensive data review, and health implications. Food Chem. 2025;463:141160.

Why this study

We used to say "mushrooms accumulate metals" in general terms. This review is the first to break down speciation — which chemical form of each element — across five key trace elements: As, Cr, Se, Hg, Sb. The form decides the toxicity — and the review shows how much we still don't know.

Methods

  • Systematic review of the literature on trace-element speciation in edible mushrooms.
  • Analytical procedures: extraction, separation, quantification (ICP-MS, HPLC speciation).
  • Risk assessment against USEPA limits.

Findings

  • Chromium — barely bioaccumulates in mushrooms.
  • Antimony — predominantly in the Sb(V) (less toxic) form.
  • Mercury — accumulates on contaminated sites; methylmercury is the main hazard.
  • Arsenic — ~10% of samples exceed inorganic-As limits.
  • Selenium — "enriched" cultivated mushrooms often overshoot safe thresholds.

Limitations

  • Fragmented data: few standardized methods, almost no work on cooking effects.
  • "Safe conditions of consumption" the authors call a still-distant goal — the data are thin.

Why it matters

The review frames all our "accumulator" cards: not "bad mushroom" but "gathering site + species + element form". For our readers: don't pick on roadsides/industrial land, rotate species, and remember — an "edible" mushroom on polluted ground becomes a different product.