Safety / toxicology 2005

The 14 mushroom poisoning syndromes: global epidemiology and syndromic classification (review of 28,018 cases)

A descriptive review of world literature 1951–2004 collecting 28,018 confirmed mushroom poisonings. Diaz proposed an expanded syndromic classification — 14 syndromes grouped by onset time (early <6 h, late 6–24 h, delayed ≥1 day) and target organ — and formally described four new ones: accelerated nephrotoxicity (A. proxima, A. smithiana), rhabdomyolysis (T. equestre, R. subnigricans), erythromelalgia (Clitocybe spp.) and delayed neurotoxicity (Hapalopilus rutilans).

Diaz J.H. Evolving global epidemiology, syndromic classification, general management, and prevention of unknown mushroom poisonings. Crit Care Med. 2005;33(2):419-26.

Rationale

Unknown-mushroom poisoning is the everyday scenario in toxicology: the clinician almost never knows the species. A classification by presentation — hours to symptoms and target organ — is what drives prognosis and management.

Methods

Descriptive analysis of world literature: observational studies 1959–2002 and reports back to 1951 — 28,018 confirmed poisonings (MEDLINE 1966–2004, OLDMEDLINE 1951–1965, library sources before 1951). Onset timing and organ target were extracted; secular fatality trends tested.

Results

14 syndromes grouped by onset:

Onset Syndromes
Early (<6 h) 8: four neurotoxic (muscarine, ibotenic acid/muscimol, psilocybin, coprine), two GI, two allergic
Late (6–24 h) 3: hepatotoxic (amatoxins), accelerated nephrotoxicity, erythromelalgia
Delayed (≥1 day) 3: delayed nephrotoxicity (orellanine), delayed neurotoxicity, rhabdomyolysis

Four newly formalised syndromes:

  • Accelerated nephrotoxicity — Amanita proxima, A. smithiana (kidneys fail within days, without hepatitis).
  • Rhabdomyolysis — Tricholoma equestre (the man-on-horseback!), Russula subnigricans.
  • Erythromelalgia — Clitocybe amoenolens, C. acromelalgia.
  • Delayed neurotoxicity — Hapalopilus rutilans.

Overall trend: since the 1950s, reports of severe and fatal mushroom poisoning have risen worldwide.

Author's conclusions

With an unknown mushroom, time-to-symptoms and target organ give the best working classification: early onset is usually benign; delayed onset warrants ICU and transplant readiness.

Worth noting

Diaz's classification underpins modern toxicology protocols — and our own lookalike cards. Its weakness: a narrative review, not a meta-analysis — syndrome estimates are qualitative, and global case distribution is skewed by publication activity (Japan and Europe over-represent Africa). A separate lesson: Tricholoma equestre appears under "rhabdomyolysis" — which is exactly what our zelyonushka card warns about.